JD Vance shows that impersonating Trump is not that easy - FT中文网
登录×
电子邮件/用户名
密码
记住我
请输入邮箱和密码进行绑定操作:
请输入手机号码,通过短信验证(目前仅支持中国大陆地区的手机号):
请您阅读我们的用户注册协议隐私权保护政策,点击下方按钮即视为您接受。
观点 美国政治与政策

JD Vance shows that impersonating Trump is not that easy

The former president’s running mate lacks charisma, charm and a sense of humour

One of the manifold remarkable aspects of the 2024 US presidential race is how quickly the news cycle moves on. Just over two weeks ago, an assassination attempt was made on Donald Trump — an episode that was expected to dominate and “reshape” the race. And yet the sheer volume of election news since then has made this feel like a distant memory. Indeed, in the past week, the number of Americans looking up “Trump shooting” online has been eclipsed by the number putting another search term into Google: “JD Vance couch”. 

The search relates to a rumour that Vance, Trump’s running mate, had confessed to having sex with a couch in the pages of his bestselling memoir Hillbilly Elegy — a rumour that, while utterly baseless, has been seized upon by meme makers. But while this is hard to blame on Vance, a series of misjudgments, blunders and a strong cringe factor are not. And those have combined to keep the senator from Ohio trending on social media for all the wrong reasons. 

Vance has made several attempts, over the past week or so, to come across as a likeable kinda guy who can crack jokes and make people laugh — a guy like Trump, in other words. The problem is that he can’t seem to pull it off. Trump is naturally very funny; Vance is not. And somehow, despite the fact that the former was born into a life of privilege while Vance was born in an impoverished home to a drug-addict mother, it is Trump who manages to come across, to his supporters at least, as a man of the people. 

Last Monday, at a rally in his hometown of Middletown, Ohio, Vance made a weird crack about how Democrats would probably call the fact that he drinks Diet Mountain Dew racist. “It’s good!” he said as a few members of the crowd laughed halfheartedly, before doing a very awkward faux laugh and pointing his finger at the crowd Trumpily with an “I love you guys”. 

A montage of awkward moments from the speech was shared widely, as was an accidentally hilarious video of Vance backstage at a rally in Virginia. In the clip, Vance goes through the “ton of crap” (including bottles of Diet Mountain Dew) that had been laid out for him to eat and drink before saying to camera, in distinctly Michael-Scott-from-The-Office fashion, “If I ate even half this stuff of course I’d balloon up like crazy,” and then asking for campaign donations.

Trump would never. Vance might be the millennial, but it is the boomer former president — perhaps because of his background in and affection for television — who has a better sense of how the moving image and the internet work. Trump often gives incredibly long and rambling speeches — I was in the crowd in 2022 when he announced he would run for the presidency again and many superfans were trying to leave before he’d finished — but he understands that it is the clips and soundbites that will be watched by millions of people and that only they really count.

Trump also has a keen grasp on the magic of plausible deniability. While Vance went on television in 2021 to rally against childless “cat ladies” — and doubled down by posting the same phrase on social media — Trump often tends to be more cunning. He deploys phrases like “a lot of people are saying” or “I’ve been hearing” in order to put some distance between himself and an offensive comment, and uses body language to signal what he really means.

“There’s a script of what he’s saying, but then there’s also a meta script of what it means to people,” Donna Goldstein, an anthropologist at the University of Colorado Boulder and co-author of a 2016 paper on Trump’s entertainment value, tells me. “A lot of it has to do with bullying other people, but it’s all done in this clownish, gesture-ish way . . . He often just gestures the final sentence, which is then highly interpretable, and so he’s off the hook.” 

Vance has a further problem that Trump doesn’t share: he has a real ideology. Trump has changed his position on abortion many times, for instance; Vance has openly called for a national ban. While Trump has started calling for unity, Vance talks about “completely replacing the existing ruling class with another ruling class” and the need to “overthrow” the “people who currently actually control the country”.

Vance is too serious for listeners to brush off his comments with an “oh he’s only joking” — something I often hear from Trump’s supporters. He lacks Trump’s charisma, confidence and comedy value, and he also lacks the subtlety of Trump’s style, which is often under-appreciated. If the former president wanted a running mate who would make him shine, Vance was a great pick.

jemima.kelly@ft.com

版权声明:本文版权归FT中文网所有,未经允许任何单位或个人不得转载,复制或以任何其他方式使用本文全部或部分,侵权必究。

欧洲增长前景受到赤字限制打击

欧洲经济还面临多项长期挑战,从老龄化社会导致劳动力萎缩,到应对气候变化和提升防务能力。

“主流媒体”能在第二届特朗普任期幸存下来吗?

美国的新闻集团担心,当选总统将通过监管、诉讼和恐吓来兑现竞选时对新闻业的威胁。

英伟达向全球芯片制造商传达的信息

英伟达向全球芯片制造商传达的信息很明确:如果不能打败它,那就加入它的供应链。

巴西的全球平衡战略比以往任何时候都更难实现

巴西总统卢拉一直寻求与美国、中国和俄罗斯都保持联系。但即使在特朗普再次胜选之前,这一外交空间也在缩小。

冗长的午餐应该为西班牙洪水预警失灵“背锅”吗?

幸存者指责西班牙地方政府失职,专家则警告气候变化正在引发更多难以预测的自然灾害。

广告商将重返X平台,试图讨好马斯克和特朗普

一些品牌曾因马斯克取消审核而放弃在该网站投放广告。
设置字号×
最小
较小
默认
较大
最大
分享×